top of page

When a Hospital Refers a Critical Patient, Who Ensures a Safe Transfer?

10 minutes ago
4 min read

A hospital’s responsibility may not end with a referral


A critically ill patient is asked to move to another hospital. But there is no life-support ambulance, no medical professional to accompany the patient, and the family is left to make emergency arrangements.


If the patient’s condition worsens during the transfer, who is responsible?


A recent decision of the Delhi State Consumer Commission brings this important question into focus. The Commission directed Metro Hospital & Heart Institute, Lajpat Nagar, New Delhi, to pay ₹15 lakh in compensation and ₹50,000 towards litigation costs after finding a deficiency in service in the arrangements made to transfer a critically ill patient.


Interestingly, the Commission did not find the treating cardiologist medically negligent. Its finding was about a different, but equally important, responsibility: ensuring that a patient can be transferred safely when a hospital recommends shifting them elsewhere.


What happened in this case?

The complainant, Suresh Kumar, had a history of rheumatic heart disease and had undergone dual valve replacement surgery at AIIMS in 2008.


In November 2013, he developed severe breathing difficulties and was admitted to Metro Hospital. Investigations revealed obstruction of the prosthetic aortic valve due to a thrombus. The treating team administered streptokinase.


However, the patient subsequently suffered a stroke. His family alleged that the hospital advised shifting him to its Noida facility but failed to arrange an appropriately equipped ambulance and a doctor to accompany him.


The family had to arrange an ambulance independently through Vimhans. According to the complaint, no doctor accompanied the patient during the transfer. The family approached the consumer forum, alleging negligence and deficiency in the hospital’s services.


The important distinction: Was the treatment negligent, or was the transfer mishandled?

The Commission examined the medical evidence and expert opinions before reaching its conclusion.


The medical board at G.B. Pant Hospital considered streptokinase an accepted treatment in the circumstances. It also noted that stroke was a recognised complication. The Delhi Medical Council found no prima facie medical negligence, and this view was upheld by the Medical Council of India.


The Commission, therefore, did not hold the treating cardiologist negligent for administering the treatment.


But that did not end the hospital’s responsibility. The Commission separately examined the arrangements made for transferring the patient. It found that the hospital had failed to provide a satisfactory explanation for not arranging an appropriate ambulance and medical supervision for a critically ill patient.


This was treated as a deficiency in service.


A referral is not simply a matter of handing over responsibility

A patient who is critically ill cannot be expected to arrange emergency medical infrastructure independently.


When a hospital advises shifting such a patient, the circumstances of the transfer matter. The patient may need oxygen, monitoring, life-support equipment or medical supervision during the journey.


A referral does not automatically absolve the hospital of responsibility for the safety arrangements within its control.


The duty is not necessarily to guarantee a successful outcome. It is to take reasonable steps to ensure that the transfer is medically appropriate and that the patient is not exposed to avoidable risks because essential arrangements were neglected.


This is particularly important when the patient is unstable and dependent on continuous medical support.


What does this mean for hospitals and patients?

The decision highlights a part of hospital care that can easily be overlooked: the period between treatment at one facility and arrival at another.


For hospitals, this means:

  • Assess the patient's condition before recommending a transfer.

  • Arrange an ambulance with equipment appropriate to the patient's medical needs.

  • Ensure that qualified medical personnel accompany the patient when clinically necessary.

  • Communicate the patient's condition and treatment details to the receiving facility.

  • Document the advice, transfer arrangements and any refusal or choice made by the patient or family.


For patients and families, it is important to ask whether the proposed ambulance is suitable for the patient's condition, whether medical supervision is required, and whether the receiving hospital is prepared to accept the patient.


The legal lesson: Medical negligence and deficiency in service are not always the same

One of the most significant aspects of this decision is the distinction between negligence in clinical treatment and deficiency in hospital services.


A medical complication does not, by itself, establish negligence. Similarly, a finding that the treating doctor followed an accepted line of treatment does not automatically protect a hospital from liability for shortcomings in its administrative or support services.


Hospitals have responsibilities beyond diagnosis, medication and surgery. Depending on the circumstances, these may include emergency support, patient monitoring, safe transfer arrangements and continuity of care.


The Commission's decision reinforces the principle that these responsibilities must be assessed independently.


Metro Hospital directed to pay ₹15.5 lakh

The Delhi State Consumer Commission directed Metro Hospital & Heart Institute, Lajpat Nagar, New Delhi, to pay:

  • ₹15 lakh as compensation for the mental agony and distress caused to the patient and his attendants, and the risk to the patient's life.

  • ₹50,000 towards litigation costs.


The total amount payable by the hospital was ₹15.5 lakh. The Commission allowed two months for compliance. In case of delay, interest at 9% per annum was directed, as specified in the order.


Importantly, the liability was imposed on the hospital for deficiency in service. The Commission did not find the treating cardiologist medically negligent.


Final takeaway

A hospital may recommend a referral, but when a patient is critically ill, the responsibility of ensuring a safe transfer cannot be treated casually.


This case is a reminder that patient safety extends beyond the treatment room. A hospital's duty may also involve ensuring appropriate arrangements when a patient needs to move to another facility.


The central question is not only whether the treatment was correct, but also whether reasonable care was taken at every critical stage of the patient's journey.


Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational and educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. The discussion is based on the Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission's decision in Suresh Kumar v. Metro Hospital & Heart Institute & Ors., Complaint Case No. 1146/2015, decided on 6 November 2026. The legal outcome of other cases will depend on their specific facts, medical evidence and applicable law.

The Author :

Dr. Sunil Khattri 

+91 9811618704


Dr Sunil Khattri MBBS, MS(General Surgery), LLB, is a Medical doctor and is a practicing Advocate in the Supreme Court of India and National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi.

 
 

Subscribe to stay updated about new blogs

Thanks for subscribing!

bottom of page